hrtechoutlook

A featured contribution from Leadership Perspectives: a curated forum reserved for leaders nominated by our subscribers and vetted by the HR Tech Outlook Advisory Board.

melin

Developing Managers into Stronger People Leaders

Ashley Smith

Managerial Development Champion

Most managers were promoted for being good at work, not for leading people. Companies then wonder why the manager layer is where engagement, retention and performance problems start. After 20 years in HR, I’ve found that developing managers comes down to five practices.

1. Define What Good Looks Like

Managers can’t improve against an unwritten standard. Before any training, write down what the company expects of a manager in plain, observable terms:

  1. Sets clear goals and holds people to them
  2. Gives timely feedback, positive and corrective
  3. Holds regular one-on-ones
  4. Makes fair, documented decisions
  5. Develops the people on their team

Assess managers against this list, and you can see where each one is strong and where the gaps are. Without it, development becomes generic training that fits no one.

2. Start with the Few Skills that Matter Most

Manager training programs fail by covering everything. Start with the three conversations managers avoid most:

  1. Setting Expectations. Most performance problems begin with an unclear goal.
  2. Giving Feedback. Early, specific, and private.
  3. Handling Underperformance. Documented, direct, and with a clear path.

Teach these first, with practice, not slides. Managers learn by rehearsing the hard conversation with someone watching, not by reading about it.

3. Build Structure into the One-on-One

The one-on-one is the most effective development tool a manager has, and the most inconsistently used. Give it a standard format:

●     Agenda owned by the employee

●     Progress against goals

●     Feedback in both directions

●     One development topic per meeting

A consistent structure means the quality of the meeting no longer depends on the manager’s instincts. It also gives HR a way to see how managers are doing without auditing them.

4. Measure Manager Performance Like You Measure Everything Else

If you track employee performance, track manager performance. The most useful measures are:

●     Completion of goals and reviews on time

●     Team retention and internal promotion

●     Employee feedback on their manager

●     Quality of documentation when issues arise

Measure these at the manager level, not just company-wide. An average hides the managers who need support and the ones worth learning from.

5. Make HR a Coach, Not a Gatekeeper

Managers go to HR late, usually when a problem is already serious. Reverse that. Show up early and often:

●     Be in the room when managers plan performance conversations

●     Offer scripts and templates, not just policy

●     Review difficult decisions before they are made

●     Give managers a fast answer, even when the answer is no

HR that is useful earns earlier involvement. Earlier involvement prevents most employee relations issues.

Handle the Hard Cases Directly

Some managers will not develop. Set a clear timeline, specific expectations and support, then decide. Leaving a weak manager in place costs more than the discomfort of acting. That cost lands on their team first, and the best employees leave first.

The Takeaway

Developing managers does not require a large program. It requires a written standard, focused training on the hardest conversations, a consistent one-on-one, honest measurement, and an HR function managers trust enough to call early.

The articles from these contributors are based on their personal expertise and viewpoints, and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of their employers or affiliated organizations.

Weekly Brief